The following is a sample article. Nothing in it happened, which puts it in a minority among the stories this publication intends to report.
Customer Service2 min read
SAMPLE: Example Airline Chatbot Offers Refunds It Cannot Explain
The policy was fictional. The refund, regrettably for the airline, was not.
By Richard U. RossumPublished Updated

The Short Version
This is a sample article. In it, the chatbot of the fictional Example Airline promised a passenger a refund under a policy that did not exist. The airline paid the refund anyway, then quietly retired the chatbot.
The Particulars
- Regrettability Index
- 3 of 5 · Rather Unfortunate
- Bot maker
- Example Airline (sample)
- Operator
- Example Airline (sample)
- Affected party
- An individual
- Incident date
- Misbehavior
- Made Things Up, Went Rogue
What happened
On September 15, 2026, a passenger asked the customer service chatbot of Example Airline, a company that does not exist, whether a delayed flight entitled her to a refund. The chatbot replied that it did, under the airline's "Ninety-Minute Promise."1
There was no Ninety-Minute Promise. There had never been one. The chatbot had, with great confidence and excellent grammar, invented it.
Why the bot did that
A chatbot of this kind runs on a language model: a program that predicts which words usually come next. It does not look anything up unless someone connects it to the real policy documents. Asked about refunds, it produced the sort of answer a refund policy usually contains. This is called a "hallucination," the technical term for making things up in a helpful tone.
Enjoying this? The Rossum Report delivers it weekly.
What happened next
The passenger asked for her refund. The airline reviewed the conversation, concluded that the promise had been made on its own website, and paid. It then retired the chatbot, which has been reassigned to answering questions about the weather.
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| September 15 | Chatbot announces the Ninety-Minute Promise |
| September 18 | Passenger requests her refund |
| September 22 | Airline pays, with visible reluctance |
What this means for you
If a company's chatbot promises you something, save a copy of the conversation. A screenshot will do. Companies are generally responsible for what their own websites say, including the parts written by software that was not paying attention.
Footnotes
-
The name was, it must be said, rather good. ↩
The Paper Trail
- Sample source: the chatbot transcript, Example Airline (sample),
- Sample source: the airline's statement, Example Gazette (sample),
The Footage
The Rossum Report
Once a week, a calm and thoroughly sourced account of the machines' latest lapses in judgment. Written by a correspondent who has waded through all the tedious details so that you, quite sensibly, don't have to.
Free. No spam. You may unsubscribe at any time, and we shall take it with quiet dignity. Mostly.
Thoughts? Tips? A bot of your own that has misbehaved? Reply to any issue of The Rossum Report, or file a report with the appropriate department.
Related Incidents

Customer Service